Results: York vs. Lincoln Christian
September 18, 2023
at York
| Division | Winning Player(s) | Varsity/JV | Defeated Player(s) | Varsity/JV | Score |
| #1 Doubles | Lincoln Christian: CJ Cuciti (11), Brady Watson (10) | Varsity | York: Kaden Heiden (12), Collin Kotschwar (11) | Varsity | 9-8(7-5) |
| #2 Doubles | Lincoln Christian: Andrew Penrod (11), Benjamin Mooss (10) | Varsity | York: John Hartley (11), Eli Nething (11) | Varsity | 8-4 |
| #3 Doubles | Lincoln Christian: Ace Calfee (9), Maxwell Fredstrom (12) | Varsity | York: Wyatt Gartner (11), Peter Dallmann (9) | Varsity | 8-1 |
| #1 Singles | Lincoln Christian: Maxwell Fredstrom (12) | Varsity | York: Wyatt Gartner (11) | Varsity | 8-1 |
| #2 Singles | Lincoln Christian: Ace Calfee (9) | Varsity | York: Peter Dallmann (9) | Varsity | 8-1 |
| #3 Singles | Lincoln Christian: Grant DeHaan (10) | Varsity | York: Daniel Burgess (10) | Varsity | 8-0 |
| #4 Singles | York: John Hartley (11) | Varsity | Lincoln Christian: CJ Cuciti (11) | Varsity | 7-9 |
| #5 Singles | Lincoln Christian: Benjamin Mooss (10) | Varsity | York: Kaden Heiden (12) | Varsity | 8-2 |
| #6 Singles | Lincoln Christian: Andrew Penrod (11) | Varsity | York: Collin Kotschwar (11) | Varsity | 8-6 |